Glossary entry (derived from question below)
Sep 28, 2010 16:38
13 yrs ago
4 viewers *
Spanish term
hoya
Spanish to English
Science
Geology
volcanoes
This is an information brochure for tourists on the geography and history of La Palma (Canaries), with a lot of references to its volcanoes. UK English.
El núcleo de Los Canarios aprovecha una gran ***hoya*** en la dorsal de Cumbre Vieja, cuyo pinar rodea el pueblo por la vertiente norte. A la ***hoya*** la cierra por el sur el volcán de San Antonio.
I was wondering about "valley" but I think there may be a more precise technical term for "hoya" in this context.
Thank you in advance for your help.
El núcleo de Los Canarios aprovecha una gran ***hoya*** en la dorsal de Cumbre Vieja, cuyo pinar rodea el pueblo por la vertiente norte. A la ***hoya*** la cierra por el sur el volcán de San Antonio.
I was wondering about "valley" but I think there may be a more precise technical term for "hoya" in this context.
Thank you in advance for your help.
Proposed translations
(English)
4 | depression | fionn |
4 +1 | (river) basin | Maria Elena Martinez |
4 | pit | Leonardo Lamarche |
3 | hollow | Juan Vilca |
3 | trench | Neil Ashby |
3 | trough | fionn |
2 | crater | Rachel Fell |
References
Photo | Bubo Coroman (X) |
Proposed translations
2 days 6 hrs
Selected
depression
Well... you did say! Can't you split the points?
3 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "I'm glad someone offered it in the end :) I agree, points should be split... but it's not allowed http://www.proz.com/faq/2869#2869 (point 2.19)
Thanks, Fionn"
+1
15 mins
(river) basin
Peer comment(s):
neutral |
philgoddard
: I don't think there are any significant rivers in the Canaries, though basin would be OK.
1 hr
|
agree |
Edward Tully
: By far the most commonly accepted term in geography.
2 days 6 hrs
|
Thanks Edward!
|
6 mins
hollow
this might be more accurate
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 22 mins (2010-09-28 17:00:42 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
A hollow is a depression or small valley surrounded by mountains. This is not necessarily related to volcanoes, but the text describes the hollow being at the other side of the "old summit" or "old peak" and closed off on the other side by the volcano. It doesn't describe a feature of a volcano, but places the hollow between the volcano and another mountain, with, apparently, the town situated somewhere in the midst.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 22 mins (2010-09-28 17:00:42 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
A hollow is a depression or small valley surrounded by mountains. This is not necessarily related to volcanoes, but the text describes the hollow being at the other side of the "old summit" or "old peak" and closed off on the other side by the volcano. It doesn't describe a feature of a volcano, but places the hollow between the volcano and another mountain, with, apparently, the town situated somewhere in the midst.
Note from asker:
Thanks Juan. Please could you explain why you think this might be more accurate in the context of volcanoes? |
57 mins
pit
a large pit.
Mi sugerencia.
Mi sugerencia.
Note from asker:
Thanks Leonardo. However, there are several villages inside this "hoya" and that makes "pit" sound rather small. |
1 hr
trench
it runs along the dorsal, in a line, and is closed at the end by the volcano....
Note from asker:
Thanks Dr Neil. I'm always a bit wary of wordmagic though. |
2 hrs
crater
not really sure, but could be - the word seems to be used for craters
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cumbre_Vieja
Stock Image: Crater of Hoya Negro, volcano at La Palma, Spain.
Crater of Hoya Negro, volcano at La Palma, Spain. Erupted in 1949.
www.dreamstime.com/item.php?imageid=13000381 - Cached
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cumbre_Vieja
Stock Image: Crater of Hoya Negro, volcano at La Palma, Spain.
Crater of Hoya Negro, volcano at La Palma, Spain. Erupted in 1949.
www.dreamstime.com/item.php?imageid=13000381 - Cached
Note from asker:
Thanks Rachel, I was wondering about this possibility and had already read the wikipedia page. Let's see if anyone else agrees with you :) |
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Bubo Coroman (X)
: I agree it's best to go by pictures or descriptions of the actual place. Along with crater I'd consider depression.
26 mins
|
Thank you Deborah - sometimes essential - yes, could be depression
|
|
disagree |
fionn
: I'd be very cautious about this, it would imply the village is either inside the crater of a volcano (extinct or otherwise) or inside an impact crater from a meteorite...
43 mins
|
1 hr
trough
This is a common geographical term for a large, deep valley-like feature.
Another option would be a depression.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs (2010-09-28 20:04:09 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
Alternatively, if it's clearly volcano-related, the correct term may well be a 'caldera' - which is a large valley formed by the collapse of a volcano system.
Another option would be a depression.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs (2010-09-28 20:04:09 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
Alternatively, if it's clearly volcano-related, the correct term may well be a 'caldera' - which is a large valley formed by the collapse of a volcano system.
Note from asker:
Thanks Fionn |
Reference comments
3 hrs
Reference:
Photo
Please see the topmost photo here... http://www.islalapalma.com/en/places/fuencaliente.html?p=los...
...it shows how, as in your text, "a la hoya... la cierra el volcán de San Antonio". (the shallow "hoya" of the village falls away into the crater). It seems logical that the "hoya" is not very deep otherwise it would not have served as a suitable site for the village. The best I could come up with for "hoya" is "depression" as in my agree to Rachel's answer. The reason I agree with Rachel is that she's the only answerer so far who's taken the trouble to research the actual site of the village which I think is essential otherwise one is guessing in the dark.
...it shows how, as in your text, "a la hoya... la cierra el volcán de San Antonio". (the shallow "hoya" of the village falls away into the crater). It seems logical that the "hoya" is not very deep otherwise it would not have served as a suitable site for the village. The best I could come up with for "hoya" is "depression" as in my agree to Rachel's answer. The reason I agree with Rachel is that she's the only answerer so far who's taken the trouble to research the actual site of the village which I think is essential otherwise one is guessing in the dark.
Note from asker:
Thanks very much for your help, Deb. You were right that depression was the best possibility because, like hoya, it doesn't refer to a specific volcanic landform, but one with any cause. The photo was great! Sorry I couldn't split the points :( |
Peer comments on this reference comment:
agree |
Rachel Fell
: good link:-)
33 mins
|
thanks Rachel! - Deb
|
Discussion
In actual fact crater and caldera are also probably OK, but they are more specific, and have their equivalents in Sp and Eng.
Thank you all very much for your help.
Note to Deb, Fionn and Leonardo: you all suggested "depression" at some point, so please feel free to add this as an answer to get the points!